Episode Description

Parents get called crazy in youth sports all the time.

But Alyson Stemas believes that label misses something important. Many parents are being asked to spend thousands of dollars, manage practices, travel, lessons, coaches, development, and expectations while receiving very little information about what their role is actually supposed to be.

Alyson joins Rhett to talk about her own experience as a competitive figure skater, raising a young competitive golfer, and building Gratis after realizing how much confusion exists between athletes, parents, and coaches. They explore parental pressure, specialization, cheating in youth sports, the tension between helping and hovering, and why better communication might reduce some of the behavior we are so quick to criticize.

Subscribe

Apple Podcasts
Spotify
YouTube

Guest Resources

• Gratis

• Alyson Stemas

Key Takeaways

• Parents are often criticized for being too involved while simultaneously being expected to manage a youth sports experience they may not fully understand.

• When parents do not know what development is supposed to look like, comparison can quickly become the only measuring stick available.

• Spending more money, adding more lessons, or chasing another competitive opportunity does not automatically mean an athlete is developing or enjoying the sport.

• A parent can understand the sport and still discover that their child simply does not want to hear coaching from them.

• Sometimes the healthiest role for a parent is not becoming another coach, but understanding enough to reinforce the language and expectations the athlete is already hearing.

Soundbites

“Parents are crazy is like the headline.”

“Parents are put in a position to be crazy because they don’t have the tools, resources, and information.”

“I want you to play golf when you’re 75.”

“If it’s Mommy saying we need to work on this this week, he’s like, ‘Don’t care. Done.’”

“Where else in life are adults cutting basically blank checks into something and expecting no control?”

Episode Breakdown with Timestamps

Watch on YouTube or Listen on Apple or Spotify and follow along

[01:11] Growing Up in a Sport That Demands Early Specialization

• Alyson shares her background as a competitive figure skater and collegiate synchronized skater.

• Figure skating complicates the common advice to avoid specializing early because athletes often need advanced skills at a very young age.

• She reflects on the difference between growing up primarily as an individual athlete and eventually becoming part of a team.

• Team sports taught her a different kind of responsibility because her performance suddenly affected people beyond herself.

[04:31] Raising a Young Athlete in a Sport You Don’t Understand

• Alyson describes entering competitive golf with her son despite having almost no background in the sport herself.

• Golf asks very young athletes to navigate etiquette, emotional control, competition, and adult environments.

• Parents are often expected to guide their children through sports they never played themselves.

• That uncertainty can quietly create pressure because parents are trying to help without always knowing what helping should look like.

[08:22] Not Every Athlete Starts From the Same Place

• Rhett and Alyson discuss the reality that some kids naturally pick up certain movements and sports more easily than others.

• Effort matters, but development is not always as simple as paying for enough lessons or training.

• Youth sports can become uncomfortable when adults struggle to accept that different athletes may have different ceilings, timelines, or strengths.

• Trying to manufacture talent can sometimes pull families deeper into the chase.

[10:00] When Parents Start Cheating for Their Kids

• Alyson shares stories of parents bending the rules during competitive junior golf.

• Golf’s honor system creates situations where parents and athletes can manipulate scores without officials standing nearby.

• Rhett questions what parents are actually chasing when a single stroke or finishing position begins to feel important enough to compromise integrity.

• The conversation raises a bigger question about when a child’s competition starts becoming emotionally owned by the parent.

[11:03] Other Parents Can Change Your Kid’s Experience Too

• Alyson recalls watching another parent intensely criticize their child during a tournament in Scotland.

• Her son immediately became more anxious simply because another parent treated the moment like something enormous.

• Kids notice the adults around them, even when those adults are not their own parents.

• Youth sports culture is shaped by the collective behavior on the sidelines, not just what happens inside one family.

[15:39] “Parents Are Crazy” Might Be the Easy Explanation

• Alyson challenges one of the most common narratives in youth sports.

• Parents are blamed for coach burnout, rising costs, pressure, and athletes leaving sports.

• But many parents are spending large amounts of money and time without having a clear understanding of development, expectations, or what success should look like.

• Without information, parents often turn to comparison because it is one of the few visible ways to judge whether their child is falling behind.

[18:32] What Does the Return on Youth Sports Actually Look Like?

• Rhett and Alyson discuss the idea of ROI in youth sports.

• For one family, the goal might be a college scholarship. For another, it might simply be joy.

• Alyson explains that her biggest goal is for her son to still love golf when he is 75 years old.

• The conversation challenges the assumption that every dollar or hour invested in sports needs to produce a résumé-worthy outcome.

[20:47] When Youth Sports Becomes About the Parent

• Rhett separates uninformed parents from another difficult dynamic: adults who are chasing validation through their child’s athletic success.

• Sports can provide recognition, status, and visible accomplishments that other areas of childhood do not always receive.

• The danger is that adults can slowly begin needing the outcome more than the athlete does.

• Families may need to ask whether the experience still belongs to the child.

[23:00] The Moment That Led to Gratis

• During a tournament in Scotland, Alyson watched her son struggle repeatedly to escape a difficult bunker.

• She realized that despite paying for lessons, tournaments, and practice, she had no idea how to help him prepare for that situation.

• A conversation with her father revealed that he had experienced the same helplessness while raising Alyson as a competitive skater.

• Different generation, different sport, same problem: parents were investing heavily without understanding how to support development between lessons.

[24:30] The Missing Space Between Lessons and Games

• Alyson describes practice as one of the biggest “black boxes” in youth sports.

• Coaches teach specific techniques and use specific language, but parents may leave a lesson without understanding what was actually taught.

• Gratis was designed to create better continuity between coaches, athletes, and parents.

• The goal is not to turn parents into coaches. It is to give them enough information to reinforce the coach’s message instead of accidentally creating another one.

[26:50] Sometimes Your Kid Just Doesn’t Want You Coaching Them

• Rhett talks about paying pitching instructors to tell his children things he already knows how to teach.

• The lesson is less about baseball knowledge and more about the parent-child relationship.

• Expertise does not automatically mean your child wants instruction from you.

• Sometimes another trusted adult can communicate the exact same message without the emotional baggage that comes with hearing it from Mom or Dad.

[28:38] Coaches and Parents May Be Speaking Different Languages

• Alyson explains how technical sports language can become useless when it is not appropriate for the athlete’s age.

• A six-year-old may not understand physics, mechanics, or even left and right the way an adult assumes they do.

• Parents sometimes sit through lessons because they are trying to learn how to translate the information later.

• Better communication can allow parents to step back without becoming completely disconnected from development.

[30:22] Reminding Is Different Than Controlling

• Rhett and Alyson discuss the difference between reminding an athlete about something they chose to work on and forcing them to train.

• Parents can create opportunities, transportation, structure, and reminders.

• Eventually, the athlete has to decide how much they actually want it.

• That tension becomes especially difficult when the parent may want development more than the child does in that moment.

[31:53] Technology Is Adding Another Layer of Pressure

• Alyson reflects on how many youth sports games are now streamed, recorded, clipped, and shared.

• Golf still offers some separation from that constant visibility.

• More cameras can mean more opportunities for family members, coaches, and strangers to watch every mistake or controversial moment.

• Youth athletes are increasingly competing in environments where their performances do not disappear when the game ends.

Final Reflection

Parents absolutely influence the youth sports experience.

But blaming everything on “crazy parents” may be too simple.

Many parents are trying to navigate expensive, competitive systems without understanding the language, the development path, or even what their role is supposed to be. That uncertainty can turn into anxiety, comparison, hovering, and pressure.

Maybe some parents do not need another warning about doing too much.

Maybe they need better information about what actually helps.

Call to Action

Subscribe and follow Surviving Youth Sports on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube.

Share this episode with a parent or coach who has ever wondered how involved a parent should actually be.

And if you have a youth sports story or perspective worth sharing, we’d love to hear it.