Episode Description
Andrew Walling’s journey doesn’t follow the typical path people imagine when they think about elite baseball players. He didn’t grow up traveling the country or playing for big-name programs. Instead, he built his foundation playing locally with friends, learning the game alongside a dad who was figuring it out in real time.
That path still led him to Oregon State, then to Eastern Oklahoma State College, and eventually Mississippi State. But with each step forward came new challenges. Injuries, pressure, missed opportunities, and moments where the game stopped feeling like a game.
From a torn UCL in high school to struggling at the Division I level, Andrew shares what it felt like to lose confidence, battle identity, and question whether he even wanted to keep playing. At one point, he was at the top. Then came the fall.
And this episode walks through the climb back.
After nearly walking away, Andrew found his way back to the game, earning an opportunity with the Philadelphia Phillies organization and continuing to build his career at the professional level.
This conversation goes beyond baseball. It’s about pressure, mental health, and what happens when your identity becomes tied to performance. For parents, athletes, and coaches, Andrew’s story is a reminder that development isn’t linear, and sometimes the most important growth happens away from the field.
“I didn’t know who Andrew was. I just knew who Andrew the baseball player was.”
What This Episode Explores
• A non-traditional path to high-level baseball
• How quickly momentum can shift in an athlete’s journey
• The mental and emotional weight of expectations
• Losing confidence and identity within the game
• Rebuilding through process, patience, and perspective
Soundbites
• “That’s where I fell in love with the process.”
• “It’s not always just results oriented… it’s all the stuff off the field.”
• “I didn’t know who Andrew was. I just knew who Andrew the baseball player was.”
• “It became a fear thing. I didn’t want to go out there and keep failing.”
• “Make how you respond to it define you.”
Episode Breakdown with Timestamps
Watch on YouTube or Listen on Apple or Spotify and follow along
[00:00] Falling in Love with the Process
• Andrew reflects on where his mindset shifted
• Development goes beyond results and stats
• The unseen work becomes the foundation
[01:19] A Different Path Through Youth Sports
• Grew up playing local baseball with lifelong friends
• No early travel ball or national exposure
• Learned the game alongside his dad
[05:43] Injury Changes Everything
• Torn UCL before senior year
• Missed a full high school season
• Forced to slow down and watch
[08:03] Struggles at the Division I Level
• Realizing talent alone isn’t enough
• Not fully prepared for the demands of that level
• Searching for direction and development
[09:59] Finding Freedom at Junior College
• Choosing development over status
• Learning how to build his own process
• Experiencing failure without fear
[15:07] Pressure at Mississippi State
• Trying to make up for missed draft opportunities
• Expectations becoming overwhelming
• Losing confidence and developing the yips
[17:15] When the Game Affects Mental Health
• Fear replacing enjoyment
• Questioning identity beyond baseball
• Considering walking away
[19:05] Rediscovering the Game
• Summer ball brings back joy
• Letting go of pressure and expectations
• Confidence slowly returning
[20:29] A Second Chance
• Unexpected opportunity with the Phillies
• Saying yes to continuing the journey
• Rebuilding with a new mindset
[26:16] Learning Through Setbacks
• Navigating injuries in pro ball
• Staying present instead of looking ahead
• Using adversity as preparation
[29:45] What Actually Matters
• Focusing on execution over comparison
• Measuring success through preparation and effort
• Parents reinforcing process instead of results
Final Reflection
Not every path looks the way we expect.
Sometimes the fall is where the real growth begins.
Call to Action
Subscribe and follow the show for more real conversations around youth sports.
Share this episode with someone navigating the ups and downs of the game.
And if you have a story to share, we’d love to hear it.
Frank Decembrino: How Adults Ruin Youth Sports
Youth sports are supposed to be about the kids. But somewhere between travel teams, private training, exposure, money, playing time, and adult expectations, it can become hard to tell whose experience it really is. Frank Decembrino, founder of Clubhouse Baseball Academy and longtime leader of the Bo...
David Durand: Expectations can Steal The Joy of Youth Sports
Expectations Can Steal the Joy of Youth Sports When does “I want to get better” become “I have to get better or I’m falling behind”? Mental performance consultant David Durand joins Rhett Parker to talk about the pressure surrounding young athletes and how quickly sports can become tied to identity,...
Eddie Smith: You Can’t Buy Your Kid Opportunities
What does a Division I head coach actually look for when recruiting your kid? University of Washington Head Baseball Coach Eddie Smith has recruited and coached players across nearly every level of college baseball, including stops at LSU, Notre Dame, Virginia, Tulane, Utah Valley, and Lower Columbi...
Alyson Stemas: Parents Aren’t Crazy. They’re Uninformed.
Parents get called “crazy” in youth sports all the time. But what if a lot of that behavior comes from parents trying to navigate a system they don’t fully understand? Former competitive figure skater and youth sports parent Alyson Stemas joins Rhett to talk about raising a competitive young golfer,...
Bill Hoopes: Parents Are Losing Themselves in Youth Sports
Parents spend years driving to practices, sitting through tournaments, paying for lessons, and helping their kids chase their dreams. But somewhere along the way, how many parents start losing themselves in the process? Bill Hoopes, longtime softball coach, tournament director, author, and founder o...
Morgan Schill: Expectations Can Steal the Joy of Youth Sports
Expectations can inspire young athletes. They can also quietly steal the joy that made them fall in love with sports in the first place. Most parents don’t set out to create pressure. They simply want what’s best for their kids. But when winning, rankings, playing time, scholarships, or even the mon...
Craig Bishop: What Parents Say They Want vs. What They Actually Chase
Craig Bishop: What Parents Say They Want vs. What They Actually Chase What do parents really want from youth sports? Most of us would say development. But when the pressure of competition sets in, do our decisions tell a different story? In this episode, Rhett Parker sits down with longtime coach, p...
Breanne Smedley: The Pressure of Being a Girl in Sports
Girls are quitting sports at twice the rate of boys by age 13 , and it’s not because they don’t love the game. In this episode of Surviving Youth Sports , Rhett Parker sits down with Coach Breanne Smedley , former collegiate volleyball player, high school coach, mental performance coach, and founder...
Jonathan Carone: Are Your Kid’s Sports Really About Them?
What if the pressure we feel in youth sports has less to do with our kids and more to do with ourselves? In this episode, Rhett Parker sits down with Jonathan Carone, founder of Healthy Sports Parents, for an honest conversation about the hidden emotions that shape so many youth sports decisions. Fr...